Environmental, social and governance (ESG) investing is rapidly gaining traction among individual and institutional investors. This approach seeks to align investment portfolios with personal values and broader societal priorities by considering factors beyond financial performance. The growing demand for ESG options has prompted many plan fiduciaries to reassess the role of these investments within their retirement plan offerings. In this context, Meghan Hannon, CRPS®, CPFA®, Senior Retirement Plan Manager, offers valuable insights into the potential integration of ESG investments in employer 401(k) plans.
Evaluating ESG Sustainability
Before incorporating an ESG investment into your corporate retirement plan, it’s crucial to understand the rationale behind this addition thoroughly. Begin by assessing whether your plan participants are interested in socially responsible investment strategies. Determine if your workforce prioritizes issues such as climate change, water sustainability, or other ESG factors. To gauge their preferences and expectations accurately, consider conducting surveys or organizing focus groups. Additionally, consult with an employer 401(k) plan advisor to help you evaluate the suitability within the context of your plan’s specific objectives. This includes considering your workforce demographics, risk tolerance, and the plan’s overall asset allocation strategy. Ensuring any ESG investments align with your investment policy statement and contribute positively to the plan’s goals is essential.
Monitoring ESG Options
As a plan fiduciary, you must follow a meticulous and documented process for selecting and monitoring any investment option in your plan, including ESG options. To fulfill this duty, it’s important to document the reasons for including ESG options in your plan, the criteria and methodology used for selecting them, and the frequency and metrics for evaluating their performance and compliance with your plan’s investment policy statement. Regularly review and update these policies to reflect the inclusion of ESG options and the factors that will be considered in their selection and monitoring.
Educating Your Employees
If you decide to include ESG options in your employer 401(k) plan, it’s important to educate your plan participants on what ESG investing is, how it differs from traditional investing, and the potential outcomes. Provide clear and accurate information about the plan’s objectives, strategies, costs and performance of various ESG options. Explain the tradeoffs and limitations of ESG investing, such as the lack of standard definitions and measurements, the possibility of underperformance or overexposure to specific sectors or regions, and the risk of greenwashing or misrepresentation of ESG credentials by some companies or funds.
Considering Alternatives
While it can be appealing for employees to align their investments with personal values, the primary objective of investing remains supporting their financial goals and future retirement. Given the tradeoffs and limitations of ESG investments, it’s key for plan sponsors to conduct thorough research and due diligence before adding ESG options to their plan lineup.
Helping You Get There…
ESG investing has evolved from a niche market to a diverse set of strategies for both financial and non-financial goals. Investors can ensure their investments align with their priorities and principles while positively impacting external causes and organizations. Connect with a Boulay retirement plan advisor to assess if ESG options are suitable for your employer 401(k) plan and learn how we’re committed to helping you get there.
Investment Advisory Services offered through Boulay Financial Advisors, LLC a SEC Registered Investment Advisor. Certain Third Party Money Management offered through Valmark Advisers, Inc. a SEC Registered Investment Advisor. Securities offered through Valmark Securities, Inc. Member FINRA, SIPC
Boulay PLLP and Boulay Financial Advisors, LLC are separate entities from Valmark Securities, Inc. and Valmark Advisers, Inc. Prime Global is not affiliated with Valmark Securities, Inc. and Valmark Advisers, Inc.